Case Of The Week - Medicare Advantage - TRA

Case Of The Week – Medicare Advantage

Written By Jenny Kiffmeyer, J.D – The Retirement Learning Center

My client is upset because he received a special notice stating his provider is cancelling his Medicare Advantage (MA) plan, effective December 31, 2026. Further, there does not seem to be any other MA plans available where he lives. What should he do?

Highlights of the discussion

Medicare is complicated, and deadlines are important. December 31st is the most important practical deadline for someone whose MA plan is not renewed at year-end, as is the case for your client. He will need to enroll in replacement MA coverage or a stand-alone Part D plan by then for coverage beginning January 1, 2027.

Help your client seek expert guidance from a licensed insurance agent or broker who specializes in Medicare ( i.e., a State Health Insurance Assistance Program (SHIP) counselor (https://www.shiphelp.org/) and/or a Medicare insurance agent or broker (e.g., through the National Association of Benefits and Insurance Professionals’ Find an Agent directory). SHIP counselors provide independent Medicare counseling; Medicare brokers help clients select and purchase insurance.

Your client’s experience is not uncommon. Many Americans must change coverage because their MA plans are being discontinued. Factors that can affect MA plan offerings include:

  • Higher costs. Insurers report that rising medical costs and utilization, together with Medicare funding pressures, are squeezing profit margins.
  • Medicare payment changes. The Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) completed the phase-in of its updated risk-adjustment model in 2026, changing how patient diagnoses affect plan payments.
  • Some areas are less profitable. Insurers may leave markets they consider financially unsustainable.
  • Provider network A hospital leaving an MA network is different from the MA plan itself being discontinued; clients should check both plan availability and participating providers.

Depending on which plans are available locally, your client generally has these options:

  • Enroll in another MA plan. Use the Medicare Plan Finder at Medicare.gov to determine if other MA plans are available in your client’s ZIP code and county. Compare providers, drug coverage, and total costs. For coverage starting January 1, 2027, enroll during October 15–December 7, 2026, or by December 31, 2026, using the nonrenewal Special Enrollment Period. That special period runs December 8, 2026–February 28, 2027; enrollments in January or February generally take effect the first day of the following month (see Medicare Special Enrollment Periods).
  • Return to Original Medicare and consider Medigap and a separate Part D plan. If your client’s MA plan is not renewed and he does not join another MA plan before it ends, he generally returns automatically to Original Medicare on January 1, 2027. Medigap is optional supplemental coverage that helps pay Original Medicare cost-sharing; it is not a substitute for Original Medicare. Your client should compare its premiums and benefits and arrange separate drug coverage if needed.

More on Medigap. Generally, the best time to buy Medigap is the six-month Medigap Open Enrollment Period, which starts the first month an individual is 65 or older and enrolled in Part B. A policy may be available later, but medical underwriting may apply unless a guaranteed-issue right or state protection applies.

An individual whose MA plan leaves Medicare or stops serving his area generally has a guaranteed-issue right to buy certain Medigap policies if he switches to Original Medicare. The insurer cannot deny an eligible application, exclude pre-existing conditions, or charge more because of past or present health problems. This does not prevent ordinary premium differences or future rate increases.

For an MA plan ending December 31, 2026, because of involuntary nonrenewal, the federal Medigap guaranteed-issue application period begins when the client receives the termination notice and ends March 4, 2027 (63 days after coverage ends). He should apply promptly and request a January 1, 2027, effective date to avoid a gap in supplemental coverage. Keep the nonrenewal notice as proof. Missing the deadline could mean medical underwriting, higher premiums, or denial unless another protection applies. Confirm eligible Medigap policies and any additional state rights with the state insurance department, Medicare (1-800-MEDICARE), or the State Health Insurance Assistance Program (SHIP).

Also, newly sold Medigap policies do not include Part D prescription drug coverage. A client returning to Original Medicare should generally enroll in a separate Part D plan unless he has other creditable drug coverage. Medigap enrollment does not enroll him in Part D.

Conclusion

When clients face nonrenewal of their MA plans, prompt action is essential to avoid gaps in coverage, medical underwriting, higher premiums, and, potentially, penalties. Confirm effective dates and arrange medical and drug coverage, as needed.

Sources: Medicare Special Enrollment Periods (nonrenewal); Medicare Part D late enrollment penalty. Part D enrollment is separate from Medigap. The dates assume year-end nonrenewal, not a different midyear termination event. 

Strengthen your retirement planning conversations.
Partner with TRA for retirement plan support and practical insights that help you bring more value to client relationships.

Pattern

Consider TRA's 3(16) Fiduciary Services & Plan Administration

To alleviate the day-to-day administrative burdens of yours or your clients retirement plans.
PLAN NOW